What you need to know about ESRS S3
01
What ESRS S3 is about
ESRS S3 is guided by international human rights standards, such as the UN Guiding Principles, the OECD Guidelines and the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. The disclosures should show users of the sustainability statement where the company’s own business or its value chain touches the rights of communities, how those affected are heard, and how the company prevents, mitigates and remedies negative impacts.
02
The 4 disclosure requirements at a glance
The disclosure requirements show which policies the company has (S3-1), how it engages with communities (S3-2), and what it does and wants to achieve (S3-3 and S3-4).
- S3-1 Policies: The policies on affected communities and whether they cover specific communities, such as the residents around a site or a community of indigenous peoples, or all of them. Particular provisions on dealing with impacts on indigenous peoples must be disclosed separately
- S3-2 Engagement, channels and remedy: Whether and how the company engages directly with communities, their legitimate representatives or credible proxies, how their views feed into decisions and, where the company takes steps to understand them, how it gains insight into the views of particularly vulnerable or marginalised groups such as women, girls, migrants or people with disabilities. Also the channels for concerns, whether a grievance mechanism exists, how effectiveness is assessed, and the approach to remedy where the company has caused or contributed to material negative impacts
- S3-3 Actions and resources: Which actions and resources the company uses and plans for its material impacts, risks and opportunities, especially against negative impacts, including where they come into conflict with other business interests, for example in land-use planning, land acquisition or the exploitation and financing of raw materials, and how their effectiveness is tracked. Also, for the material sub-topics, the human rights incidents in the reporting period
- S3-4 Targets: Which qualitative or quantitative targets the company has set on affected communities
03
Indigenous peoples and FPIC
Indigenous peoples have particular rights. Central among them is free, prior and informed consent (FPIC). It comprises 3 interrelated rights: the right to be consulted, the right to participate, and the right to their own lands, territories and resources.
- What must be disclosed: where indigenous peoples are affected, how the company takes into account and respects their rights in its engagement, including the right to FPIC. This concerns their cultural, intellectual, religious and spiritual property, activities affecting their lands and territories, and legislative or administrative measures that affect them. Where engagement takes place, also whether and how they were consulted on its form and process
- Where it becomes relevant: often in the value chain, for example in mining, agriculture and forestry, or large energy and infrastructure projects
- Climate action can have impacts too: A transition plan for climate or biodiversity can touch the lands and resources of indigenous peoples. Actions against negative effects of the transition to a low-carbon and climate-resilient economy must be presented so that the connection stays visible, for example when mines close or the extraction of minerals increases
- Other communities: The right to FPIC belongs to indigenous peoples only. For all other communities, the company must disclose whether and how it engages with them and which channels are open to them for their concerns. Legal disputes over land rights must be considered here too when identifying human rights incidents
04
Reporting human rights incidents correctly
Only incidents that are substantiated and verified are reported. Substantiated means: objective, factual and verifiable information evidences the case. Verified means: a court, the OECD or an administrative authority has made a formal finding that it occurred. Not every ongoing proceeding and not every other registered case is substantiated.
- Severity decides: Whether an incident is material depends mainly on the severity of the impact. When identifying incidents, legal disputes over land rights and over the consent of indigenous peoples must always be considered
- Summarise rather than list: Incidents can be grouped by type or by affected communities; an individual list is not necessary
The disclosure applies to the material sub-topics and is subject to data protection rules.
05
Phase-ins
Like E4, S2 and S4, S3 may be deferred in full:
- First wave: now only for financial year 2026. This includes companies that report for the first time for financial year 2026. Companies that, at the balance sheet date, do not exceed at least one of the two thresholds (EUR 450 million net turnover or an average of 1,000 employees) may in any case omit all topical standards for financial year 2026 if they already apply the new set
- Other companies: for their first 2 reporting years, so for financial years 2027 and 2028 if the reporting duty starts with financial year 2027
The deferral is not entirely free. The company must state whether the topic is material. If it is, it must briefly describe the topic or the material sub-topics, how business model and strategy take the impacts into account, time-bound targets and progress, policies, and actions with their result, and it must disclose the relevant metrics.
06
Typical data sources in the company
The starting point is the sites and the raw materials:
- Site management, permits and environmental impact assessments show conditions, objections from residents and known conflicts over noise, traffic, emissions or land
- Grievance channels and whistleblowing systems provide concerns from outside, provided they are also open to residents and third parties
- Procurement and supply chain risk analyses show countries and regions of origin of critical raw materials and thus where communities or indigenous peoples may be affected
- Legal and compliance keep the files on proceedings about land rights, neighbour disputes and complaints, and the contracts with security service providers
- Freely available tools such as the LandMark map of the lands of indigenous peoples and communities or the database of the Business & Human Rights Resource Centre show where land rights and conflicts are known
07
How it relates to the VS standard
The VS standard contains no metrics of its own on affected communities. In the comprehensive module, the company must state whether it became aware of confirmed incidents in the reporting period that involve affected communities; this is voluntary for up to 10 employees.
08
Typical mistakes and challenges
These points often come up in practice:
- Passing off donations, sponsorship and support for local clubs as an S3 policy. S3 asks about impacts on the rights of communities. Community engagement does not replace a policy on negative impacts. Positive contributions do not offset negative impacts
- Looking for communities only at your own site. Material impacts can often lie in the raw material chain, especially in regions where indigenous peoples live
- Relying blindly on supplier data. Self-declarations alone often do not show whether land rights are being violated in a raw material region. They can be supplemented by on-site audits, recognised certifications and own research in sector and regional data, media reports and conflict databases