What you need to know about ESRS S4
01
What ESRS S4 is about
ESRS S4 is guided by the international human rights standards, such as the UN Guiding Principles and the OECD Guidelines. From the disclosures, users of the sustainability statement should see how products, marketing and data use affect the people who buy or use them, how those people have their say and how the company prevents, mitigates and remedies negative impacts.
02
The 4 disclosure requirements at a glance
The disclosure requirements show which policies the company has (S4-1), how it engages with consumers and end-users (S4-2) and what it does and wants to achieve (S4-3 and S4-4).
- S4-1 Policies: the policies on consumers and end-users and whether they cover specific groups, such as certain age groups, or all of them
- S4-2 Engagement, channels and remedy: how the company engages with consumers and end-users, their legitimate representatives or credible proxies, and how the perspectives of consumers and end-users feed into decisions. If the company specifically seeks the perspectives of groups that are particularly vulnerable or marginalised, such as children or people with disabilities, this is included as well. In addition, the channels for concerns, whether a grievance mechanism exists, how the effectiveness of the channels is assessed and how the company provides remedy or cooperates in it if it has caused or contributed to material negative impacts
- S4-3 Actions and resources: the key actions and resources for material positive and negative impacts, risks and opportunities. For material negative impacts, also the actions taken, planned and under way and how their effectiveness is tracked. In addition, for the material sub-topics, the human rights incidents in the reporting period, as far as data protection allows
- S4-4 Targets: which qualitative or quantitative targets the company has set on consumers and end-users
03
Conflicts with sales, marketing and data use
Impacts often arise where the business itself acts: in marketing, sales and data use. That is why, under actions, the company must describe explicitly how it proceeds when consumer protection conflicts with these business interests, for example with advertising aimed at children, lending to over-indebted customers or the analysis of personal data. For human rights incidents, the same standard applies as in S2 and S3:
- Substantiated and verified: only cases are reported that are supported by objective, factual and verifiable information and that a court, the OECD or an administrative authority has formally established
- Severity decides: whether an incident is material depends mainly on the severity of the impact
- Aggregate instead of listing: incidents can be grouped by type or by the groups affected
04
Phase-ins
Like E4, S2 and S3, S4 may be deferred entirely:
- First wave: now only for financial year 2026. This also covers companies that report for the first time for financial year 2026. Companies that, at the balance sheet date, do not exceed at least one of the two thresholds (EUR 450 million net turnover or an average of 1,000 employees) may omit all topical standards for this financial year anyway if they already apply the new set
- Other companies (required to report only for financial years from 2027): for their first 2 reporting years, so for financial years 2027 and 2028 if the duty applies from financial year 2027. What counts is the legal duty, not the date of national transposition
The deferral does not free companies entirely. They must state whether the topic is material. If it is, they must briefly describe the topic or the material sub-topics, the link to the business model and strategy, targets and progress, policies and actions, and disclose relevant metrics.
05
Typical data sources in the company
Much of the information often exists already, spread across familiar areas:
- Customer service and complaint management, often in the CRM or ticket system, provide concerns, escalations and how easily the channels can be reached
- Quality management and product safety know about recalls, safety tests and notifications to market surveillance authorities
- Data protection provides the record of processing activities, reported personal data breaches and proceedings before the data protection authority
- Marketing and legal know the advertising guidelines, requirements on child protection and accessibility, as well as cease-and-desist letters and proceedings under competition law
06
Link to the VS standard
The VS standard contains no metrics of its own on consumers and end-users. In the basic module, initiatives on product safety are among the practices that can be disclosed; in the comprehensive module, companies must state whether they know of confirmed incidents involving consumers and end-users. For companies with up to 10 employees, this is voluntary.
07
Typical mistakes and challenges
These points come up in practice:
- Classifying S4 as immaterial because the company sells only to businesses. End-users also exist in B2B business, for example customers’ employees who use software, or patients with medical devices
- Reporting customer satisfaction instead of impacts. Satisfaction scores and ratings say little about whether users’ privacy, safety or access is affected and whether they can raise their concerns effectively
- Leaving out sales and marketing. How conflicts between consumer protection and business interests are handled is explicitly asked for